One of the highlights of your wedding and reception is the cutting of the cake. Most couples have the traditional wedding cake, but if you are a cheesecake lover (which many people are), do you dare to be different? We will provide you and your guests with a classy Cheesecake that will WOW them! Cheesecake Cutie will provide cheesecakes that will have your guests talking about the "cake" you had at your wedding for months to come.
Our Cheesecakes are made from scratch on site in our Holmes Beach, FL location and every cheesecake is made with you and your special day in mind. You can taste the difference with our cheesecakes for that very reason, plus they are made with so much love. We know that everything must be as close to perfect as possible on your very special day and you can count on us to do everything we can to give you that.
Our past Bride and Grooms have chosen our 9" Full Cheesecakes for cutting and the 2" Cheesecake Cuties for their guests as they are individual servings. This allows your guests to choose what flavor they would like if there are choices.
We want to make this part of your wedding planning easy, so we have simple pricing.
$8.50 per person for any flavor. ($102.00 per dozen)
Starting at $55.00 are our 9" Full Cheesecakes
We will deliver to any Anna Maria Island location for $35.00.
Wedding Party Breakfast or Lunch?
Looking to provide breakfast or lunch to your wedding party on the BIG day? Let us cater this for you as well. Our Café can provide any of our breakfast items from our menu. How about delicious sandwiches, freshly made green salads or deli type salads, 1-2 bite Skewer appetizers and even an impressive charcuterie board. We can put together individually "boxed" meals, platters or even allow your party to make their own sandwiches with our cold salads. All our of items are family recipes that we are bringing to you and we take pride in every item we make.
Call or Email us to discuss your event details. You will always speak with the owners Jennifer or Kane when planning.
Click below to read an editorial about us in the Wedding World
"Jennifer is wonderful and the cheesecake here is fantastic! We had Cheesecake Cutie for our wedding cake on the island and we could not be happier with the results. I would highly recommend you try this place out. The Cheesecake made our wedding day sweeter and they tasted just as good as they looked!" - Jack & Katie Kiwiet 1/24/21 Sandbar Restaurant
"My daughter got married 06/08/2021 in Anna Maria Island. Cheesecake cutie provided the cheesecakes for the wedding! They were amazing! Jennifer makes the best cheesecake I have ever tasted. My guest were very impressed by her cheesecakes! Jennifer also catered my welcome party I had for my guest! Her Charcuterie Boards had the best deli meat and amazing cheese's on them! You have to try her Scuties, and the Sweet and Savory Flatbread was out of this world! Jennifer also served us lunch at the salon we were at getting our hair done the day of the wedding! Jennifer and her husband went above and beyond for all my events that week! Cheesecake Cutie Is an Anna Maria GEM! Jennifer Thank You for all your help!" - Jan Davis 6/6/21 Beach House
"Thank you for this lovely cake. Not only was it beautiful, it was delicious!" (9" Cheesecake with flowers pictures above)
-Christopher Funk 10/8/21 Beach House
"They are amazing! Jen is so accommodating too! They catered a wedding breakfast for us. Can you say delicious? We had breakfast burritos, flatbreads, fruit, coffee and don’t forget the scrumptious cheese cake cuties!!! Mmmmm. We liked it sooo much that my guests and myself ordered lunch the next day from them!!"
- Janet Mroczka 10/8/21 Breakfast Catering
"We recently hired The Cheesecake Cutie for our wedding and I simply can’t say enough about how wonderful they were. I reside in Illinois and to plan a wedding and purchase/trust that what you are getting is difficult to do when you haven’t tasted or seen anything you’re getting prior to the day of. We received so many compliments about them! People who told me they “weren’t cheesecake people” even loved them. We chose to just do the cuties for the wedding in three different flavors, Blueberry Lemon, White chocolate raspberry, and Juan in a Million (Oreo) all were delicious. Every person had their own favorite. Biggest surprise was how big they were! I don’t know that anyone could finish the whole thing after dinner.
Thank you to the owner Jennifer who was extremely kind, professional and helpful throughout the process."
-Cassie Owens 10/18/21 Beach House