top of page
Click the Logo to be directed to our page & place your order!
Direct Order &
Pick up only from Café
Voted 2022 Favorite Sub/Sandwich on Anna Maria Island!
Our sandwiches are the true meaning of Handcrafted!
Sandwiches
Cutie Combo
Make your Lunch a Cutie Combo ! Add Chips and a Drink! Add $4.00 the sandwich price. Cheesecake Cutie Combo
Make your Lunch into a Cheesecake Cutie Combo. Add a Drink, Chips & a Cheesecake Cutie +8 to sandwich priceBBQ Turkey Bacon Ranch
Turkey, Cheddar Cheese, Bacon, Ranch, BBQ Bacon Jam on a Pretzel Roll
$13.40
The Best Cluckin' Chicken Salad
AMI Favorite! House Chicken Salad, Romaine Lettuce on an Italian Hoagie.
$13.35
Classic BLT
It's a Biggin'! Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato on toasted white bread.
$11.95
Cool As A Cucumber
Cream Cheese, Cucumber, Red Onion, Cheddar Cheese on Toasted Rye.
Make it a "Suzy Q" and add Turkey for $4.00 additional
$12.05
Vegetarian
Cordon "Ramsey" Blu
Rotisserie Chicken, Ham, Swiss, Arugula, House Dijon Mustard on a Pretzel Roll
$12.95
Fat Ass Proscuitto
Home of the Fat Ass! Prosciutto, Arugula, Garlic and Herb Goat Cheese on an Italian Hoagie.
Make it a "sassy fat ass" and add Balasmic $.75
$14.55
Greek Hippie
Humus, Lettuce, Cucumber, Tomato, Red Onion, Feta, Greek & Black Olives on a Pita, House Greek Dressing.
This could also be Vegan by removing Feta Cheese.
**Make it Vegan and remove Feta cheese
$12.05
Vegetarian
Vegan
Horse Roast Beast
Seasoned Roast Beef, Pepper Jack Cheese, Red Onion, Tomato, Lettuce, House Horseradish Mayo on Ciabatta.
$14.35
Knuckle Sandwich
grilled cheese
Choice of Bread: White or Marble Rye
Choice of Cheese: Cheddar, Gouda, Pepper Jack, Provolone or Swiss
$11.35
Vegetarian
Old Bay Shrimp Roll
Old Bay House Shrimp Salad, Romaine Lettuce, on an Italian Hoagie
$16.45
Vegetarian
The "little" Joey Italian
Ham, Sweet Sopressata, Genoa Salami, Provolone, Oregano, Red Onion, Iceberg Lettuce, Lady's O's House Italian on an Italian Hoagie.
$13.40
Lox'n It Up
Choice of toasted bagel.
Smoked Salmon, red onions, tomato, capers & fresh ground pepper.
$16.45
Caesar Pleaser
Mrs. Cutie's Favorite
Romain Lettuce, Rotisserie Chicken, House Caesar.
Available on a Regular or Spinach wrap
$12.40
Pita Plate
This dish is perfect for our Vegan/Vegetarian Friends! Pita wedges, Cucumbers, Tomato, Greek Olives and Hummus.
$11.85
Vegetarian
Vegan
The Whole Cow
half-pound italian marinated filet of roast beef, bell peppers, red onions, provolone cheese, drizzled with cutie honey dijon sauce
$20.85
The Unusual Buffalo
toasted ciabatta, rotisserie chicken drenched in cutie's unusual buffalo sauce, pepper jack cheese, and piled high with apple cider ranch cole slaw!
$17.73
Table Salads
Caeser Pleaser
Rotisserie Chicken, House CaesarSmall
$12.55
Large
$20.35
Chicken Salad
Our Chicken is freshly with herbs (at time right from our onsite garden). An AMI Favorite for sure! Small
$12.55
Large
$20.35
Old Bay Shrimp Salad
With the taste of Maryland, we have created the most delicious Shrimp Salad. Fresh, light and simply like no other around.
An AMI favorite!Small
$16.55
Large
$26.85
Green Salads
Dressing Choice:
Lady O's House Italian, Lady O's House Greek, House Caesar, Raspberry Walnut & RanchCutie Salad
Romaine, Cucumber, Red Onion, Tomato, Greek Olives, Cheddar Cheese & House Croutons.
$9.25
My New Option
Ham$4
Chicken$4
Turkey$4
Caesar
Romain Lettuce, Fresh Shaved Parmesan, House Caesar
$9.05
Vegetarian
My New Option
Ham$4
Chicken$4
Turkey$4
Click on the Menu you wish to view
bottom of page