Chicken Salad

An AMI Favorite

The "Little" Joey

Italian

The Triple-Decker Club

The FAT ASS

Prosciutto, Goat Cheese

& Arugula

Cordon Ramsey

Ham, Chicken & Swiss with a

Honey Mustard Mayo

The Greek Hippie - Vegetarian

Lettuce, Tomato, Cucumber, Red Onion

Feta Cheese & Humus. 

Ham, Arugula & Spicy Jam

​Beefy Horse

Roast Beef, Horseradish Mayo

Italian VEG

Vegan & Vegetarian

The Rockin' Shrimp Roll

Old Bay Shrimp Salad

AMI Favorite

Spicy Buffalo Wrap

Cuban Cutie

Caesar Pleaser

The Island Cowboy

BBQ Chicken, Bacon, Cheddar

& Ranch

The Old Fashion

Ham & Cheese

Our Cafe is a new addition to the Cutie brand and we couldn't be more excited about it.  Kane is our brilliant creator of all the unique selections and bringing our family recipes to Anna Maria Island. Kane's love of food started as a child watching his grandmother cook after school. As he grew up, it was always something that he loved and was very good at making anything taste amazing. There will always be something new and creative on the menu.

Make sure you stay up to date with us. We post the Daily Menu on our Instagram and Facebook pages. 

Our goal is to bring freshly made Salads, Scuties and mouth watering Sandwiches to everyone who walks into our store.

​

Pre-order your favorite for the next day or Call ahead and we will have your sandwich ready for pick up. Don't stop there, order a Cheesecake Cutie or some Crust Cookies to go with it.